We are pleased to present the July 2017 edition of TLD Group Buzz, our quarterly e-newsletter designed to share important topics and trends impacting the healthcare ecosystem. As organization development consultants, seasoned executive coaches, and academicians, TLD Group’s team strives to weave the latest trends into our customized client solutions. For more information on how TLD Group partners with our clients to capitalize on these and other leadership trends, visit our Solutions page. Please send any comments and feedback to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Healthcare Ecosystem Leadership Model (HELM™) Spotlight: David Carmouche, Ochsner Health Network
▸ N.C. Providers to Collaborate for Underserved Communities
▸ Cleveland Clinic, Humana Highlight Data Partnerships in a Value-Based Climate
▸ Health Insurers Go All in on Value-Based Drug Pricing
▸ Collaborating a Necessary Component of Success
HEALTHCARE ECOSYSTEM LEADERSHIP MODEL (HELM™) SPOTLIGHT
David Carmouche, MD, is Senior Vice President of Ochsner Health System and President of Ochsner Health Network in Louisiana. In his current role, David is responsible for clinical integration, population health strategies, development of a data and analytics infrastructure, care management, network administration and insurance product development. David joined Ochsner with 19 years of progressive healthcare leadership experience in medicine and operations. Before joining Ochsner, Dr. Carmouche served as the Executive Vice President of External Operations and Chief Medical Officer at Blue Cross Blue Shield of Louisiana in Baton Rouge where he successfully led important initiatives designed to organize care, improve quality, and increase affordability.
- Understanding your potential partner’s business models and mindset are important first steps for developing mutually-beneficial collaborative solutions.
- Opening up a partnership dialogue driven by inquiry as opposed to forced solutions helps quell tensions bred from historic misunderstanding and lack of trust.
- Innovative, collaborative solutions do not develop overnight – it takes time to identify a shared vision, align stakeholders, and overcome obstacles. Patience, persistence, and grit are key competencies for success.
- We would all make progress if we had more people who had the skills and capabilities to reach across sectors and put themselves in the other side’s shoes.
TLD Group: In your current role, how do you define your health ecosystem?
Carmouche: Our ecosystem consists of several sectors that come together to create the environment within which our organization operates. The first sector is the provider sector comprised of the Ochsner Health Network (OHN). Second is the payer sector. Ochsner Health System is a high-performing network that is viewed as a value opportunity for purchasers. Third is the health sciences industry, whether its manufacturers, device companies, pharmaceuticals. Lastly, the technology and health IT sector has become an increasingly big part of our organizations’ ecosystem, whether it’s in big data, analytics, consumer engagement, or connectivity.
TLD Group: What role do you believe your organization plays in improving population health?
Carmouche: We believe we lead improvements in population health in the state of Louisiana. I view our role through the following three lenses:
- History of risk-taking and population health management
Ochsner Health System has a history of managing risk. We were the first provider-sponsored health plan in the state of Louisiana. We have been a leader in downside risk contracts in that we bore the risk of health insurance costs for our 20k employees as well as 35,000 Medicare Advantage members. We have been a Medicare ACO longer than any other entity in the state. Our influence is reputational because we have had the most experience leading this kind of work. We believe, therefore, that we not only can but should be the leader in improving population health in the state.
- Focus on social responsibility
Louisiana has the largest burden of illness of any state, so we feel a great sense of social responsibility. For this reason, we are also very active in driving state policy. For example, the decision by the current governor to expand Medicaid in Louisiana was something that Ochsner not only supported heavily, but we also helped craft its implementation.
- Clear experience and commitment to collaboration
Our organization’s growth occurred in two stages. After Hurricane Katrina, we grew through acquisition because many for-profit hospital companies abandoned the New Orleans market, and Ochsner was the only viable entity to come in and take ownership of many of those hospitals. Our growth beyond that has been through partnership and collaboration, because we have a vision to be an aggregator, and not necessarily growing by acquiring greater assets. We have had a significant impact in the New Orleans area, where most of our assets are located. However, we realize that to drive better outcomes for the whole state of Louisiana, we have to develop a collaborative state-wide structure. In this way, we can work with local entities to disseminate Ochsner’s experience to other regions while leveraging local brands and clinical strengths.
TLD Group: What are the most pressing challenges you face in trying to impact the health of New Orleans, and the state of Louisiana at large?
Carmouche: The biggest challenge to impacting population health, in general, is that the programmatic approaches make financial business sense only in a model where healthcare is pre-paid. The reality is that Louisiana is largely fee-for-service. In essence, we are working against ourselves. In population health, the financial rewards are acquired when people are kept out of the hospital. The challenge is trying to help move the payment model at a pace that keeps up with the changes of the value-based operational model we are trying to implement. There is an inherent misalignment in the incentives for those paying for care (health insurance companies) and those providing care (health systems). For example, during my time as an executive at Blue Cross, we would discount the years when there was a big hurricane in Louisiana. In hurricane years, we were more profitable because people were still paying their premiums but unable to access care. In my experience at Ochsner, we also discounted a hurricane year when evaluating historical financial performance, because in these years, our operational performance was completely decimated. These two organizations, representing different sectors of the same health ecosystem, both discounted the impact of a natural disaster because one made an unusually high profit and the other had unusually poor financial performance.
TLD Group: What do you think can be done to ameliorate this misalignment between reimbursement structure and care delivery?
Carmouche: I believe the payers need to come to the realization that the current business model has utterly failed to deliver better health outcomes at a lower price (i.e. broad access networks, leverage gain to control unit prices, and utilization management programs to try to pre-empt unnecessary services). There are limitations to the payer’s historical approach to reimbursement. Unless they want to employ doctors directly or purchase hospitals and run them, they are going to have to work with the providers within their communities to create a win-win financial relationship. To create alignment, we need to bring the major payers at the table with providers to create a different financial relationship that aligns both players.
TLD Group: How did you identify Blue Cross as a potential partner and encourage collaboration?
Carmouche: Several payers want to work with Ochsner in a variety of ways, but we honed in on Blue Cross partly because of a willingness to collaborate in a meaningful way, and partly because of their influence in our markets. And, since they are not-for-profit they have the ability to be more nimble because they aren’t beholden to some corporate entity or board that is responsible to shareholders. More importantly, though, it’s because Blue Cross believes that engaging in a unit price battle with providers is not the path to keeping healthcare premiums affordable; rather, it’s through incentivizing providers to move to value.
Once we identified Blue Cross as a potential partner, we then engaged their new CEO. Both Ochsner’s and Blue Cross’ CEOs saw their respective organizations as “shapers” of the healthcare ecosystem in Louisiana, and rapidly discovered a shared vision of what the two could do together. We needed their help in terms of moving the payment model, allowing us to have access to some data and information that would make us more effective, and they needed our help transforming our care model to reduce utilization and lower our total cost of care. In the case of Ochsner, it was through aligning us in a business model that allows us to share in the profitability of the insurance products that are built on our network. Once we identified the mission, the main challenges were taking that vision and overcoming barriers to implementation.
TLD Group: Can you give an example of some barriers and how you’ve tried to overcome them?
Carmouche: For OHN to be successful, we need to be able to sell narrow-network products. Narrow-network plans offer cheaper premiums which appeal to price-sensitive consumers. If we are going to be taking utilization down and if the per-capita reimbursement to Ochsner is going to decrease, then we need more capita. The way to grow more capita is to either capture more of the healthcare services within our system or to bring new people into our system who don’t historically get their care here. That requires a narrow-network vehicle that has benefits designed to keep people within our system. The challenge is that most of the business that we’re going to go after is controlled by brokers. Blue Cross has mastered the distribution of their products through great relationships with brokers, but brokers don’t like narrow networks because a) they don’t understand them, b) they have to deal with a lot of post-sale complaints by employees who are no longer able to go to the physician or facility of their choice, and c) their brokerage fees are the same for selling these products even though they require more work. For us to collaborate successfully with Blue Cross, we needed to consider how to change incentives for brokers. It’s been very difficult for Blue Cross to think through how to do that because they’re very afraid of disrupting their relationship with their brokers. To overcome this, we pulled together a meeting between some of their most influential brokers, Blue Cross’ sales and marketing team, and my team at Ochsner, to explain that our imperative is to lower the cost of health insurance, and that the way for Ochsner to do that and remain viable and successful is through narrow network products. It was really important to open that dialogue with the brokers because it could have potentially been a disruptive move in the marketplace. Much of the feedback we received from the brokers was that, had we not brought us all together and explained that vision, they probably would have fought us tooth-and-nail. We had to align all the players because everyone comes in with their different priorities for their own organization. By opening up the dialogue and laying everything out on the table in a very transparent way, we were able to come up with a collaborative solution.
TLD Group: What was your role in facilitating the collaboration?
Carmouche: I am the only member of Ochsner’s senior management team that comes from a payer background, giving me a unique perspective to anticipate potential obstacles and suggest methods to overcome the roadblocks in a win-win manner. For example, if someone on my team starts speaking from a position that is historical or from a provider-focused angle that I know is in conflict with how the payer views the world, I’ll call it out and help them understand the other side’s position. Getting both parties to understand the other’s side is very difficult, though. If you can paint your position in a very clear-cut, understandable, and factually-based manner, that tends to move people. If you can also figure out what the “middle ground” looks like, and what each side has to do to get there, that tends to be an effective way to move people who are hesitant. Even the most recalcitrant people tend to take a step forward when they see that the other party is willing to meet halfway. That’s the tactic that’s been helpful for me.
TLD Group: How would you recommend leaders, who only operate in a single sector, develop the capacity to foster these types of conversations?
Carmouche: The thing that stymies progress the most in healthcare is a lack of understanding of each other’s business objectives, priorities, and challenges. It is amazing the misperceptions that have been generated over decades that have persisted today that are just factually incorrect. If you’re an organization envisioning a future that involves cross-sector collaboration, but your leaders only have experience within one sector, the best thing to do is to gain an understanding of your cross-sector partners’ business model and way of thinking. This could be done just by asking the right types of questions, and getting the partner to open up and share how they view the world. Leaders could also ask to spend time within their partner’s organization, which creates opportunities for learning in their environment. We need many more people with the ability to foster cross-sector collaboration. This is a skillset that can be developed. The reason these leadership skills are important is because once you create an understanding and accurate perceptions, a lot of the resistance barriers dissipate quickly. I would say that we would all make progress if we had more people who had the skills and capabilities to reach across sectors and put themselves in the other side’s shoes.
TLD Group: What would you say has been your “key learning” from your experiences trying to impact change within your organization?
Carmouche: I have had to learn to take a longer-term view. I am not a patient person – I see an opportunity and have a vision for our organization that is so powerful to me that I want to get to it immediately. For me, the leadership lessons haves been: a) you’re not going to hit a home run on every complex initiative, and b) there is value to just having the discussion itself. Not reaching the desired solution immediately doesn’t equate to failure. Just opening up the dialogue and having the conversation makes the organization better and is part of their growth. For me, it’s having to learn to view it as a learning process that takes time and persistence.
TLD Group welcomes the following new clients and projects:
- New York-Presbyterian – Hudson Valley Hospital is a fully accredited general, voluntary, not-for-profit 128-bed Hospital serving the community with high quality health care through their team of more than 450 physicians and 1,300 employees.
- Centura Health is a non-profit, faith-based health care system based in Englewood, Colorado that was formed in 1996 as a joint operating agreement between Catholic Health Initiatives and Adventist Health System.
- Academy for Applied Physician Leadership (AAPL) 3.0 with Palomar Health. On May 25, 2017, TLD Group kicked off our 3rd Applied Physician Leadership Academy© with Palomar Health in northern San Diego County. Palomar’s 3.0 program is designed to further the development of its medical directors by building self-awareness and practical leadership skills aligned to their new medical director role. Alan Friedman, CEO of J3Personica, facilitated the first session on self-awareness using feedback from the Hogan assessment. Stephen Beeson, MD, Founder of Practicing Excellence, will facilitate the program’s five core leadership development learning modules with supplemental interactive application using The Clinician Effectiveness Project. Click here to learn more about our physician leadership academies.
Health Ecosystem Leadership Research
As part of our series on health ecosystem leadership, we are pleased to present our interviews from two outstanding leaders who demonstrate leading collaborative solutions for the industry’s most pressing concerns.
Roland Lyon, president of Kaiser Permanente (KP) of Colorado, leads the state’s largest nonprofit health plan, providing healthcare to approximately 670,000 members in Denver/Boulder, Southern Colorado, Northern Colorado, and the mountain communities of Summit and Eagle counties. Lyon joined KP in 2002, initially based in California before coming to Colorado in 2006. His roles in California included vice president of consulting and capital planning in KP’s Northern California region, and vice president of strategic planning in KP’s national program offices. Click here to read our interview with Roland.
Craig Samitt, MD, MBA is the EVP and Chief Clinical Officer at Anthem, where he is responsible for establishing, leading, and executing overall clinical vision and strategy for Anthem, the second largest health insurer in the US. In this role, Craig leads all clinical operations and policy as well as Anthem’s diversification strategy, from payer as a benefit-management company to payer as partner, enabler, and convener. An internal medicine physician by training, Craig has worked across multiple sectors within the health ecosystem including providers, payers, and policy makers. His work specializes in turnaround management, growth of physician networks, enhancing integrated delivery systems, and diversifying health plans in competitive markets. Click here to read our interview with Craig.
Applied Physician Leadership Academy© (APLA™) Case Studies
APLA™ is TLD Group’s customized physician leadership development program grounded in our research-based physician leadership success model, focusing on developing physician leaders to execute on strategies for organizational success. Our case studies of recent APLA client work demonstrate how APLA develops physician leaders to execute on strategies for organizational success.
- Reading Health System: The goal of RHS’ APLA was to champion its physician leaders to drive system change, and to strengthen the relationships between the organization’s physicians and administration.
- Palomar Health: The organization recognized the need to develop its clinical (physician and nurse) leaders as partners in team-based care delivery to be better positioned for the future of value-based care.
- Atlantic Health System: The system’s administration recognized the importance of engaging and developing its physician leaders to enable them to become effective members of the management team in order to position the system for success.
TLD Group President Tracy Duberman and senior advisor John Larrere published an article in Trustee Magazine entitled, “Co-creating Strategy.” This article discusses an innovative approach in which hospital boards and management co-create strategy to more effectively perform their traditional oversight duties and increase their ability to make major contributions to the direction of the hospital and health system enterprise. Click here to read the article and learn more about our board services here.
HealthLeaders Media Article
Reading Health System CEO Clint Matthews was interviewed for an article in HealthLeaders Media about his partnership with TLD Group to launch the Applied Physician Leadership Academy (APLA™). This article, entitled, “Want to Recruit and Retain Physicians? Invest in Them” highlights key points from the interview and the success of Reading’s APLA. Click here to read the article and here to learn more about APLA.
Coaching in Leadership & Healthcare 2017 Conference
TLD Group will be presenting a poster entitled, “A Three-Tiered Approach to Building Collaborative Leadership through Assessment & Partnership Coaching, Action Learning, and Interactive Classroom Training”, at the Coaching in Leadership & Healthcare 2017 conference on October 13-14. Our poster demonstrates how CHI-Texas Division utilized an innovative Partnership (Dyad/Triad/Tetrad) Leadership Model, where administrative, physician, nurse, and/or academic leaders are partnered at every hospital, service line, and market across the health system. To learn more about the conference, click here.
Becker’s CEO/CFO Roundtable Conference
TLD Group will be presenting a panel session at Becker’s CEO/CFO Roundtable Conference on November 13-15, 2017 with Clint Matthews, CEO of Reading Health System and Michael Covert, CEO of CHI – Texas Division. The panel session, entitled, “Creating Healthcare Leaders: Aligning Development with Strategy Execution” demonstrates these CEOs’ clear commitment to leadership development for physicians, administrators, and nurses through their innovative leadership development academies. Click here to learn more about Becker’s CEO/CFO Roundtable Conference.
American Association for Physician Leadership (AAPL) 2017 Annual Meeting
TLD Group presented with Alan Conrad, MD, (VP, Physician Integration) at the American Association for Physician Leadership (AAPL) 2017 Spring Institute on April 21-23, 2017, in New York, NY. Our presentation, entitled “Innovative Solutions for Engaging, and Retaining Top Physician Leaders” described the journey of Palomar Health in engaging and integrating physician leaders as change agents through a physician leadership development process. Click here to view the presentation.
AHA Physician Leadership Forum
TLD Group’s Director of Client Solutions, Tara Satlow, PhD, and senior consultant Margaret Cary, MD, MBA, MPH, presented a webinar for the American Hospital Association’s (AHA) Physician Leadership Forum on June 8th, entitled, “The Art and Science of Storytelling to Engage and Inspire Healthcare Teams.” In this webinar, we:
- Explained the science of storytelling as an emotional and physiological influence practice
- Employed practical tools, techniques, and tips for developing the art of leading through narrative
- Described how stories enhance team engagement, purpose and connection
HEALTHCARE ECOSYSTEM LEADERSHIP SUCCESS STORIES
Cross-sector collaboration guides much of our work and that of our clients. We are pleased to share recent success stories from across the health ecosystem. These examples demonstrate the innovative thinking and practical application of health ecosystem leadership and its impact on health outcomes.
N.C. Providers to Collaborate for Underserved Communities
Hospitals & Health Networks
Two historically competing health systems in North Carolina, Carolinas HealthCare System and Novant Health, have decided to collaborate to tackle issues of access to primary care as well as the social determinants of health in underserved communities.
As the healthcare industry continues to shift toward value-based reimbursement, payer-provider partnerships have great implications for patient care in terms of data sharing and analytics. These “data partnerships” pave the way for innovative solutions to value-based payment models.
Health Insurers Go All in on Value-Based Drug Pricing
Collaboration between the payer and pharmaceutical sectors of the health ecosystem may be the solution for value-based purchasing of prescription medications. Organizations from these respective sectors have begun to form partnerships to explore the possibility of value-based payment models.
Collaborating a Necessary Component of Success
The pharmaceutical industry has begun to recognize the value of collaborations, both inside and outside of the industry, to change the focus from selling medicine to managing population health. This article highlights the potential for collaborations between pharmaceutical companies and a variety of unique partners.